XenForo mastered the forum software. Now is time to go beyond with a road map.

Penguin

Aspirant
Joined
May 10, 2015
Messages
15
I respect the idea but I don't see that as revolutionizing XenForo or any forum software at all. When you sign up for Reddit, you're signing up for just that, Reddit. You're not going to my gaming forum signing up and instantly getting access to other sites in the hub because you're a member on my site. Didn't Tapatalk do something like this recently whereby being a member on the app you have access to multiple forums?

If anything I'd prefer for the whole subreddit thing to be permission-based in XenForo. Let users create nodes that'd act like subreddits that they have minor permissions too. Basically, copy Reddit's ability for users to create their own sections and create content meaningful for that category.

xenforo.com/r/gaming
xenforo.com/r/design

This could satisfy the whole group concept and really give the potential to create something rather engaging for the community as a whole. Obviously not revolutionizing but just tweaking your concept a little.
This is where I find the IPB Clubs system to come in useful here, as you could create a club for each 'subreddit' or category. Alternatively, have a 'Create Forum' form that sends an API Request to create a forum based on the users' input. The Clubs system is major innovation, which we won't know if XF will ever have due to lack of roadmap.
 

sbjsbj

Fan
Joined
Feb 9, 2015
Messages
681
If anything I'd prefer for the whole subreddit thing to be permission-based in XenForo. Let users create nodes that'd act like subreddits that they have minor permissions too. Basically, copy Reddit's ability for users to create their own sections and create content meaningful for that category.

xenforo.com/r/gaming
xenforo.com/r/design
What you describe is basically groups. I don't think this will make any kind of impact. Because in a groups system, yet again, you expect from the users to create something magically, which they won't do in forums anymore. It is too tiresome.


I respect the idea but I don't see that as revolutionizing XenForo or any forum software at all. When you sign up for Reddit, you're signing up for just that, Reddit. You're not going to my gaming forum signing up and instantly getting access to other sites in the hub because you're a member on my site. Didn't Tapatalk do something like this recently whereby being a member on the app you have access to multiple forums?
But you miss the point here. Yes, when you sign up to reddit, you are signed up to it and you have access to all subreddits.

And I propose the same thing for the XFHub. When you sign up to the hub, you have access to all forums in the hub. So the hub displays the newest and coolest posts from all forums across on the mainpage. So one big place where you have access to all of it. And then you can subscribe to subXFs, which basically registers an account on your gaming forum. So 1 single sign up to the hub and 1 click to "subscribe" signs you also up to your gaming forum, all done by API. It uses the same e-mail you used for the hub, it takes the same username and if the username exists, it creates the same name but with numbers (Blizzard, Twitch, Twitter style naming system). So one display name you can freely choose, even duplicates and one unique name (numbers attached to it when duplicate) which is generated based on your display name.

Tapatalk is popular because exactly of that. One app and you have access to all forums. Ofc. you need to register to single one of them, but with my proposition you only need to do it once on the hub, that's it. And Tapatalk is an app, so specizilaied for mobile display and mobile use. The XFHub would be working for all plattforms.
 
Last edited:

MagicalAzareal

Magical Developer
Joined
Apr 25, 2019
Messages
725
This is where I find the IPB Clubs system to come in useful here, as you could create a club for each 'subreddit' or category. Alternatively, have a 'Create Forum' form that sends an API Request to create a forum based on the users' input. The Clubs system is major innovation, which we won't know if XF will ever have due to lack of roadmap.
Clubs was implemented first in vB3 back in, I believe, 2007.

It is not an IPB innovation, however IPB seems to have it polished a lot better, unlike social groups which looked like it was quickly hacked together and bolted on. I've administrated a forum with vB3 social groups and it was quite frankly... awful.

vB3 did get a few things right which no one has done to this day like letting people customise their profiles and what-not.
 
Last edited:

DaveL

Habitué
Joined
Feb 4, 2007
Messages
1,416
So, you are saying, when I buy windows 8 or 10, in one year later, I should pay the update fee for security and stability updates? I have never heard of such thing where I pay the renewal fees for the security and stability updates. I thought, wait, I just don't think, by EU laws you have to provide me for 24 months for FREE any kind of guarantee stuff (securit and stability), at least for tangible things. Non-tangible things will be from 2021 and on union-wide.

Also, I do think the words UPDATES and UPGRADES have the same meaning or the gist is the same, as they can be used as synonyms.

View attachment 53006

View attachment 53007


Yes, nowhere do they promise any updates/upgrades. But I think it is faily trivial to expect updates/upgrades, when they charge you a fee for that stating it is for updates, too.

So, my expectation being "nowhere near software development", is fairly comical, don't you agree?

It is like I pay for Netflix, and they tell me I pay for the "security and stability" of the Netflix app, and I don't get to see the newest movie releases they have in their sortiment. I only get those from 2015 because that was the time I paid for it the first time. That is your angle right now making for XF, telling us that the fees people pay are for that (of course not exclusively, apart ticket support).

And I still don't understand that saying, can you explain? Not American/British here.
This 24 month EU rule is nonsense. Care to link to it?
 

sbjsbj

Fan
Joined
Feb 9, 2015
Messages
681
This 24 month EU rule is nonsense. Care to link to it?
Sure.

https://theadminzone.com/threads/92-of-my-users-prefer-ips-over-xenforo.149830/page-8#post-1139530

See the screenshot of the fact sheet.

You are in the UK I believe according to your avatar, right?

You already have these laws btw. and so do other EU countries, but nothing unionwide right now, which will happen latest in 2021.

https://www.which.co.uk/consumer-rights/advice/can-i-get-a-refund-on-a-digital-download
 
Last edited:

Russ

Administrator
Joined
Oct 20, 2011
Messages
1,337
What you describe is basically groups. I don't think this will make any kind of impact. Because in a groups system, yet again, you expect from the users to create something magically, which they won't do in forums anymore. It is too tiresome.



But you miss the point here. Yes, when you sign up to reddit, you are signed up to it and you have access to all subreddits.

And I propose the same thing for the XFHub. When you sign up to the hub, you have access to all forums in the hub. So the hub displays the newest and coolest posts from all forums across on the mainpage. So one big place where you have access to all of it. And then you can subscribe to subXFs, which basically registers an account on your gaming forum. So 1 single sign up to the hub and 1 click to "subscribe" signs you also up to your gaming forum, all done by API. It uses the same e-mail you used for the hub, it takes the same username and if the username exists, it creates the same name but with numbers (Blizzard, Twitch, Twitter style naming system). So one display name you can freely choose, even duplicates and one unique name (numbers attached to it when duplicate) which is generated based on your display name.

Tapatalk is popular because exactly of that. One app and you have access to all forums. Ofc. you need to register to single one of them, but with my proposition you only need to do it once on the hub, that's it. And Tapatalk is an app, so specizilaied for mobile display and mobile use. The XFHub would be working for all plattforms.
So you want XF to create a "hub" that users would sign up for and get access to all of the forums on there which would be XF clients who want to put their site on there. I just don't see how this works well.

On the topic of groups, I suppose I've yet to see an implementation of groups that's anywhere active as a lot of these subreddits you can find. Does anyone have any links to actively posting group functionality?
 
Last edited:

Kevin

Oooh, something shiny!
Joined
Jul 13, 2004
Messages
3,440
we won't know if XF will ever have due to lack of roadmap
Does IP and WBB have public facing feature roadmaps? Just curious, it's been some time since I've really checked out IP in detail to remember if they do or don't. I know they post about features they're working on in the betas but don't recall an actual roadmap. I have some licenses over there I should really renew one of these days. WBB, I have no idea about them.

So you want XF to create a "hub" that users would sign up for and get access to all of the forums on there which would be XF clients who want to put their site on there. I just don't see this how this works well.
XenZoints? :cautious::LOL:
 

DaveL

Habitué
Joined
Feb 4, 2007
Messages
1,416
Sure.

https://theadminzone.com/threads/92-of-my-users-prefer-ips-over-xenforo.149830/page-8#post-1139530

See the screenshot of the fact sheet.

You are in the UK I believe according to your avatar, right?

You already have these laws btw. and so do other EU countries, but nothing unionwide right now, which will happen latest in 2021.

https://www.which.co.uk/consumer-rights/advice/can-i-get-a-refund-on-a-digital-download
Yeah, That's called the mysterious EU law in the UK.

It's totally wrong how you have read it. Full details here : https://blog.moneysavingexpert.com/...must-last-a-minimum-two-years-rule-is-a-myth/
 

Karll

Adherent
Joined
Dec 9, 2011
Messages
441
We need to establish a network of XF communities with a hub.

What is reddit? Not talking about the upvotes or threaded reply styles here. Reddit has a main page (let's call it the hub) and from there one can visit so many niche categories. There is for everything a community on reddit. And the most upvoted, liked stuff get seen on the mainpage. And one can subscribe to subreddits and get the latest feeds on the mainpage. And so on.

We need exact the same thing for forums, let's say for XF. We need a XF hub, where all licensed XF communities can register their websites (if they want) and that way we have created our own reddit with XF sites.
I like a lot of what you said in this post. I had a similar idea some time ago, the 'channel node', which I posted about both here and earlier on XF.com. Unfortunately, I was apparently light years ahead of my time, so very few people appreciated the concept :) The difference between your idea and mine is that mine has a perhaps tighter, but configurable integration between the forums, and there is no single central hub, but multiple, possibly competing networks, each without any central hub, but automatically copying and sharing selected content between the participating forums.

I think the general idea of "forum networks" as a way to achieve some of the benefits of social media sites is worth exploring further.
 

sbjsbj

Fan
Joined
Feb 9, 2015
Messages
681
So you want XF to create a "hub" that users would sign up for and get access to all of the forums on there which would be XF clients who want to put their site on there. I just don't see how this works well.
Well, this is how reddit does it though.
The reddit mainpage (hub) lists all the feeds from your subscribed subreddits and the reddit/r/all subreddit lists the most upvoted topics in all of its subreddits.

So thanks to this system any kind of subreddit has a chance to get featured on the main hubs of reddit. Then, by word of mouth, people suggest other people other subreddits they never heard of. Also you can search in the reddit search with keywords for subreddits with your interests.

Reddit is exactly as a forum but it does what other SM do, they serve a hub. But of course, you might not like the idea, all good. In my opinion this idea is the next step in the forum evolution game. As our userbases get smaller and smaller over time, we need to combine all of our userbase together in one hub and channel our userbase into one hub and profit from the hub. Nothing stops us to get indexed by Google. So people still will find us through Google, but by this system we have closed ecosystem of XF-boards which all can get featured and profit from all forum users. So a 2nd system to get discovered, not just by Google.


On the topic of groups, I suppose I've yet to see an implementation of groups that's anywhere active as a lot of these subreddits you can find. Does anyone have any links to actively posting group functionality?
I agree and that is why I don't think having a groups system will make a difference. You yourself say that you have to see a good implementation of it. Imagine we would have a good one (they praise the IPS one), what would it change? It adds cluster to the forum system, just like profile fields. It is confusing and nobody knows how to use it.

The best examples are probably Facebook groups, which of course profit from again, having 2.7 billion userbase. Their sheer number dominates it and nobody has to leave ever Facebook. You will find everything in one place, for any niche there is a group.

Another example to backup my idea. We, as forums, need also a hub were all of our forums are united in one place. I mean think about it, for us nothing changes. We still have to get a valid domain, still host our own forum, any of us. The hub is hosted outside by our monthly payments and by a connected API it swallows from all participating XF forums the data and has an upvote system, directory, categories, etc.




Yeah, That's called the mysterious EU law in the UK.

It's totally wrong how you have read it. Full details here : https://blog.moneysavingexpert.com/...must-last-a-minimum-two-years-rule-is-a-myth/
Not sure what I read wrong. See the screenshot of the factsheet, it is clear as the sky.


I like a lot of what you said in this post. I had a similar idea some time ago, the 'channel node', which I posted about both here and earlier on XF.com. Unfortunately, I was apparently light years ahead of my time, so very few people appreciated the concept :) The difference between your idea and mine is that mine has a perhaps tighter, but configurable integration between the forums, and there is no single central hub, but multiple, possibly competing networks, each without any central hub, but automatically copying and sharing selected content between the participating forums.

I think the general idea of "forum networks" as a way to achieve some of the benefits of social media sites is worth exploring further.
Yep, your idea is similar to mine. Yours however is too tight and too competing. And there is no central mind which controls everything. Your idea wants the synchronisation between 2 boards with each other for example. But what if board nr2 has a bad server? The synchronisation shouldn't be between boards themselves.

upload_2019-6-19_21-10-24.png

It should be one way only, and the forums should send their content to the hub and the hub receives everything.

Yours would be between forums and not ideal, as yours also wouldn't solve the problem of finding new forums. There is no visibility advantage in your idea. Mine would feature everyone on the main hub, upvoted by users.

But I totally agree with you that we need a "network" in general. So your or my idea can have problems, we can brainstorm and work it out. The gist of your idea and my idea are the same. And I believe this could boost the forum world to another level.
 
Last edited:

Russ

Administrator
Joined
Oct 20, 2011
Messages
1,337
Well, this is how reddit does it though.
The reddit mainpage (hub) lists all the feeds from your subscribed subreddits and the reddit/r/all subreddit lists the most upvoted topics in all of its subreddits.

So thanks to this system any kind of subreddit has a chance to get featured on the main hubs of reddit. Then, by word of mouth, people suggest other people other subreddits they never heard of. Also you can search in the reddit search with keywords for subreddits with your interests.

Reddit is exactly as a forum but it does what other SM do, they serve a hub. But of course, you might not like the idea, all good. In my opinion this idea is the next step in the forum evolution game. As our userbases get smaller and smaller over time, we need to combine all of our userbase together in one hub and channel our userbase into one hub and profit from the hub. Nothing stops us to get indexed by Google. So people still will find us through Google, but by this system we have closed ecosystem of XF-boards which all can get featured and profit from all forum users. So a 2nd system to get discovered, not just by Google.
If the goal is to share users I suppose you could convince a few like-minded users to do something like Multi-site: https://xenforo.com/community/resources/xencentral-multisite-system-2.6966/

Your idea though doesn't really seem to revolutionize forums as a whole but is rather an attempt to help dying/small forums gain a new userbase to hopefully obtain more posts. Reddit works well for a number of reasons and best of all they let you create subreddits on their own site for free. I'd say the majority of people who invest money into forums want to keep their userbase to themselves and not really advertise there is X number of other forums just like theirs in the "XFHUB".

Don't get me wrong either, I absolutely love Reddit, I think it's a great site with some really helpful communities on there. I just don't see how a network of XF forums is revolutionizing forums. I'll leave it at because I think I have said it all multiple times :D.
 
Last edited:

sbjsbj

Fan
Joined
Feb 9, 2015
Messages
681
If the goal is to share users I suppose you could convince a few like-minded users to do something like Multi-site: https://xenforo.com/community/resources/xencentral-multisite-system-2.6966/
Nah, the goal is not to share users. The idea is to accumulate visitors in one single place. Like a news place. 1 place would get all the stream from across all forums participating. So the idea is to make the life for anyone easier and quicker.

Your idea though doesn't really seem to revolutionize forums as a whole but is rather an attempt to help dying/small forums gain a new userbase to hopefully obtain more posts. Reddit works well for a number of reasons and best of all they let you create subreddits on their own site for free
My idea is not unique, as I said, technically nothing new. The new part is their is no such system right now. And I would say bigger forums would profit more than small boards as they have more content. And nobody has to participate anyway, just who wants. So if it is only small boards, then it is only small boards.

Creating subreddits is the equal of creating groups. Again, that already can be accomplished with any forum right now. You could also dedicate categories/nodes for groups. All for free for the user. This stuff can be expanded right now with or without a hub. This is just a matter of a good addon, nothing more. What I propose is bigger than this.

I'd say the majority of people who invest money into forums want to keep their userbase to themselves and not really advertise there is X number of other forums just like theirs in the "XFHUB".
Again, nobody forces anyone. All XF license owners can participate if they want. If they think they would have a disadvantage, no problem, don't be a part of it.
But right now all forums compete on Google anyway. That is already the case. The search console shows what your rank is etc. That wouldn't make competing harder, but easier. Right now you live or die with Google. With a hub, you have more opportunities to land users. Much easier. And subreddits compete with each other too, nothing stops anyone to create the same subreddit.

Don't get me wrong either, I absolutely love Reddit, I think it's a great site with some really helpful communities on there. I just don't see how a network of XF forums is revolutionizing forums. I'll leave it at because I think I'd said it all multiple times :D.
Well, yeah, we both said everything what we could. I see your angle and understand. No problem.
 

Joel R

Fan
Joined
Nov 24, 2013
Messages
806
Some thoughts in no particular order:
1. sbjsbj You should check out the Mastodon Project or Tapatalk. They're already doing what you're wanting.

2. Over on Invision Community, we have the ability to offer clubs. Users can create 4 different kinds of clubs (public, private, open, closed), and my community becomes a federation of the smaller clubs. Three of my clubs are in the top 10 destinations of my community according to Google Analytics.

We're already doing what you're wanting at the community-level.

3. In general, asking independent forum admins to opt-in to a regulated platform goes against the very premise of why we started independent communities to begin with. The ones who opt-in will most likely be the weak ones. The successful communities won't feel a compelling need to opt-in, especially if it means being regulated or moderated beyond their own control.

Does IP and WBB have public facing feature roadmaps? Just curious, it's been some time since I've really checked out IP in detail to remember if they do or don't. I know they post about features they're working on in the betas but don't recall an actual roadmap. I have some licenses over there I should really renew one of these days.
No, they don't publish a roadmap either.

They just do posts of product updates.
 

sbjsbj

Fan
Joined
Feb 9, 2015
Messages
681
Some thoughts in no particular order
To 1.
As said, Tapatalk focuses on mobile experiences. I know that my idea is not unique, but as I said, the new part is that no forum software does have a hub like this run officially by their companies. Tapatalk is not XF or IPS or vB.
Mastodon seems interesting, but again, it is run outside of our closed environments. We need sth which represents our environment. Like all XF boards, or al IPS boards.

To 2.
As I said, on the community level it is just a groups addon. And I think it is confusing, non-trivial for a normal user. Even I, who has experiences, gets confused with group systems in forums. It is too much clutter and buried in the forums.

To 3.
Who said the platform would be regulated? Is IPS regulating right now all the customer's websites who use the IPS software? No. It is up to the domains holder or the server's location who is responsible. Having a hub doesn't change that. The hub is just a melting point, not regulated by anyone. Of course the hub would need regulation from a server point of view (someone has to provide working servers to host the hub, which will be paid from our fees).

Other than that, why regulate? Of course we could have nsfw filters and other type of filters for the visitors and illegal websites can't be on the hub obviously, but other than those, any site which follows the laws of the hub's located country is in. The moderation of each website is just like right now, each forum has to deal with itself.

Even if it is only the "weak ones" who opt-in, still a win for them. But I definitely think you underestimate the power of centralization of sites. Reddit is the best example. The biggest subreddits are featured on daily basis there, like AmA, or AskReddit or videos or gifs or gaming or funny. Not sure why suddenly this shouldn't be applied to big boards, who have more content and core users than anyone else? It would be parade day for them daily.

But, again, I don't think this kind of an idea would ever be implemented. I just wanted to provide a constructive criticism. I told so far what is wrong with forums in general and wanted to provide an example what could be done to save forums in general. But I know of course this is just utopia and nothing like on the level of an simple groups addon. I think I said everything I could say on this topic.

I genuinely want a response from Chris D about the other stuff we talked earlier, I mean the coasting of XF.
 

phatcows

Adherent
Joined
Nov 15, 2015
Messages
253
It would be totally wrong if the directives in the fact sheet were from 2010 (when money saving expert posted).

The European Parliament adopted the directives on 26th March 2019, and the Council formally accepted the Parliament’s position on 15th April 2019.
The factsheet is also dated 2019.

Of course, we all know that a directive sets out a goal that all EU countries must achieve, but it is up to the individual countries to create/modify their own laws to meet that goal, and they have 24 months to get there.
Money saving expert's post still applies until these laws have been amended. So maybe sbjsbj jumped the gun a little (as the laws have not been amended in UK (and likely any EU country) yet) but he's not totally wrong.
 

sbjsbj

Fan
Joined
Feb 9, 2015
Messages
681
But I said, that the laws will be followed through the latest in 2021 and that they were accepted some months ago. All in the linked thread I talked about this.
See:

upload_2019-6-20_4-44-50.png

And not to forget, these laws are there to make a unification with all EU members. It is not like right now all EU members have no laws or rules about these stuff, they do, but of course all individual and not united.

And UK has for example the digital act laws which was made in 2014 or 2015 if I remember correctly. The blog post is indeed from 2010, which I hadn't noticed, thanks phatcows

So all of my points are valid.
 

palhanow

Enthusiast
Joined
Jun 23, 2016
Messages
166
Coming back to the topic again (maybe it was my fault it escalated in a different direction, sorry).

If we are talking about "now is time to go beyond", my vision is one step further than CMS, pages, addons and things on that level.

I believe I have a real innovative idea how one could save forums and rise again. Technically speaking the idea is not very new, but it was never made from any forum software (I believe).

Now, let's forget addons, or improvements for mobile use or apps or new frameworks. What I suggest is to do what reddit does the best (which is of course also copied).

We need to establish a network of XF communities with a hub.

What is reddit? Not talking about the upvotes or threaded reply styles here. Reddit has a main page (let's call it the hub) and from there one can visit so many niche categories. There is for everything a community on reddit. And the most upvoted, liked stuff get seen on the mainpage. And one can subscribe to subreddits and get the latest feeds on the mainpage. And so on.

We need exact the same thing for forums, let's say for XF. We need a XF hub, where all licensed XF communities can register their websites (if they want) and that way we have created our own reddit with XF sites.

So there is one hub page where we can see the latest and most hot topics around all XF boards, and at the same time we can visit subXFs (like subreddits), for example XFHub.com/theadminzone directs you to this place. So one big place where all XF communities have a place. This way we can increase the engagement, we all can have more visitors as more visibility and it makes it easier for users to move around and maybe require one time registration for all XF boards.

Right now we are on the mercy of Google that one random visitor finds our forums, and even if they do, they don't bother to register or post.

But with the XFHub, we now have another big thing for visibility and engagement. It makes discovering much much easier. When I click on "new posts" on the hub, I just don't see the newest posts of theadminzone, but I see the newest posts of all XF forums the ones I am subscribed to, like on reddit).

I believe with an API one can establish a system. And to host the XFhub, we of course have to pay a fee to be on the system. There are thousands of XF boards I will never have the chance to know. Not because I am not interested in them, just I don't know how to discover them. I am pretty sure any forum owner feels like that. That they feel they have a very special place, but because Google is the only way of getting discovered, we are just sitting and waiting.

Think about how Twitter, or Facebook works. Same thing as reddit. One big place and you can subscribe to twitter users or facebook pages/users and read their feeds.

We need exact the same thing for forums, then we 100% can compete with SM, because users are already used to this kind of system. We just need to create the same thing for our sites.

Not sure if my description was good enough,a quick mockup:

View attachment 53019

So like a link directory for all XF forums, but like reddit style or Social Media style.
Oh! I'm sorry, i did not make myself clear on my last post.

Is not a bad thing that this thread escalated like this. Is a good thing and for sure that I'm agreeing with all your comments, we share a long list of same thoughts.

In my humble opinion, the Forum model is still a success since the 80's, when it all begins. Social networks are coming and dying with the time. Facebook is just a question of time to everybody go out, same with Instagram, in long terms speaking.

Nobody anymore open a business thinking solo on social network. Yes, is important to make a institutional page for your businesses but is not the same thing like 5 years ago.

Social networks dye because the only focus is people, is the artificial image created for each user to show the greatest aspects of their lives, mainly false. It's like a showcase for people. And i don't know why, spiritual reasons (why not?) but this works for a limited time and people make money with this, of course.

Of course we did loose some of the user base for social networks, but this is good in some point of view. We lost the bad posters for the fast interaction model of the social networks.

But we have a card in the hand: the content. Forums are still a success because they focus in one thing: content.

Nobody enter in some Facebook or Twitter looking for some content. They go for the chitchat. Any content posted in social networks is going to miss in matter of days.

A good and proper administration of a Forum can make even a Wiki inside, using the features that every major forum have: Threads and permissions.
Now I'm going to implement a Wiki inside my Forum, with the help from the ThemeHouse guys, with the focus on content again.

Well, maybe I'm wrong, but we are still here in the internet.

In the Reddit point of view, why they make this huge success? Because they did manage to merge some of the aspects of the two models: social networking (without the people's showcase) and Forum. People + Content + Easy using = Reddit.

And why a Forum cannot go in the same way? We must go after the innovation, taking some risks and try to modernize the same old good model from the 80's.

I think the Reddit idea for Forums is a great point to start in this pursue for the future, totally viable. After reading your post i did contacted the guys from ThemeHouse to give the idea to create a plugin that can give the administrators the option/permission to make a up/down vote model in some nodes or even posts!

Why not try this? I really cannot see the problem and the critics about it. Just give the option to the administrators, is their choice to use or not use the feature.

The content is a good point for Forum but it is a flaw in the same way. Forums are totally locked in the administrator point of view about the subjects discussed inside any Forum around the internet.

Reddit nailed this aspect of permitting the users to create their own "hubs" with their own subjects (another major feature that XF don't have) and well, like the other fellow said in this thread: The hubs get more access in the Forum.

I really believe that if us take some some shots, our chances to grow more greatly increase. Is time to face the problem: Forums need to be modernized and they are nothing near of this.

ThemeHouse seen's to be more proactive in this aspect. They have many good addons, look for the Post Comments for example, giving more a "Facebook" feeling, without loosing the Forum aspect.

In my Forum I'm trying to modernize a little my Community. The Post Comments add on is going to be my next move. Today I'm going to install the Covers plugin, to give more customization to my user base.

I hope the Reddit plugin come true someday.

Again, very nice to see this thread growing with so many informative content by the community.

XenForo devs, if you guys are reading this, is time to take some chances, ASAP.

Like i said, you guys nailed the Forum software, now is time to go move on and try new things or catch up with the competition.
 

Chris D

XenForo Developer
Joined
Aug 23, 2012
Messages
810
I have been keeping an eye on this thread but while we're taking the feedback on board, I don't think a deep and in-depth discussion about some of the points raised is productive for anyone, so I will pick a single comment and reply to that and that will be the last I have to say on the matter. Conveniently, it was the very last point raised, but I believe it answers the fundamental question as well:
Like i said, you guys nailed the Forum software, now is time to go move on and try new things or catch up with the competition.
Thank you for the kind comments about what we have achieved so far with forum software. You're right, we've done a lot of good with our forum software and every step of the way we have worked towards a more stable, more extensible and more feature-rich experience for our customers.

But we have not "nailed it" as you put it. We never will. Nor will we ever stop trying. Our job isn't complete. Our job is to continue developing the software and beyond as we and our customers see fit.

We will not be publishing a roadmap and our stance on this has been made clear in the past. What we will do is make the process for making feature requests clearer, and aim to improve our transparency in terms of what we may be minded to work on in the future. Currently the things we are minded to work on, as demonstrated with XF 2.1, are the things that our customers have told us they want to see - those being the features that have been suggested and have significant backing.

We have a number of projects in the pipeline and we will have more to show you when they are nearly complete.
 

DaveL

Habitué
Joined
Feb 4, 2007
Messages
1,416
But I said, that the laws will be followed through the latest in 2021 and that they were accepted some months ago. All in the linked thread I talked about this.
See:

View attachment 53022

And not to forget, these laws are there to make a unification with all EU members. It is not like right now all EU members have no laws or rules about these stuff, they do, but of course all individual and not united.

And UK has for example the digital act laws which was made in 2014 or 2015 if I remember correctly. The blog post is indeed from 2010, which I hadn't noticed, thanks phatcows

So all of my points are valid.
Except the UK won't be in the EU in 2021, so not quite!
 
Top