Mac Vs Windows

TLChris

Administrator
Joined
Jan 2, 2020
Messages
254
After leaving the world of computer repair as a Geek Squad Agent working in-home and on-site for enterprise...I went all in on mac.

Luckily, I've used macs since make that switch. Personally to save a few bucks I'll buy a refurbished or even used apple. The mac mini that I use as a home server came from Craigslist, and I souped it up with maxing the ram and installing an SSD. If you don't need cutting edge technology, and can handle basic repair, I'd go the refurbished route.
 

BigPete7978

Aspirant
Joined
Mar 18, 2020
Messages
33
I think both have their positives and negatives. I have had both Macs and Windows machines, and like both of them for various reasons. It all comes down to what you are trying to do.
 

User37935

Neophyte
Joined
May 4, 2011
Messages
0
This thread has been resurrected from the dead! ;)

My very old (>10 years) Macbook Pro died recently. I'd held off upgrading to another MacBook as the prices went silly, the ports disappeared on newer models, the keyboard went faulty apparently and it become non user repairable. My MacBook Pro has had a new SSD, new RAM, multiple new batteries, a new motherboard connector from Hong Kong. Try doing that on a modern Mac!

Unfortunately I couldn't find a windows laptop that felt so nice to use, so a few weeks ago bit the bullet and got the base 2020 MacBook Air. It's so nice, I am really pleased with it. The new keyboard is excellent, the speed surprising (so quick compared to my old Pro but bear in mind how old it was) and I am learning to live with dongles and adapters. Shame I won't be able to fix it or replace the battery myself but it is a lovely machine.

Ignore all the YouTube videos telling you to get the i5 model (influencers mainly, paid to promote products), the base i3 is fine for most stuff. Though it probably wouldn't do 4k editing well (you'd get a MacBook Pro for that, or a well specced PC desktop).
 

Taylor J

Fan
Joined
Mar 13, 2010
Messages
873
I actually just got my first Mac product around 2 weeks ago (purchased it from B&H).

I got the newest Macbook Pro with a few of the options specced out (more ram and the better GPU). I wanted something to be able to continue on my path of learning to program but to be able to do it from anywhere rather than sit on my gaming rig all day and also get tempted to play games rather than learn to program and I also wanted something that wasn't Windows and to try something new (I have also wanted a Mac since I was 12).

So far it's been amazing. I love the keyboard and it's amazing to type on. It has taken some time to adjust to though and I'm either mis typing a lot or having to hit backspace a lot (I haven't used a membrane keyboard in many many years and have been only using mechanical keyboards).
 

User37935

Neophyte
Joined
May 4, 2011
Messages
0
It has taken some time to adjust to though and I'm either mis typing a lot or having to hit backspace a lot

Yes, it's very easy to hit 4 keys at once on these, I'm having to look at the keyboard a lot rather than the screen to keep coordinated!
 

Chemical

Aspirant
Joined
Feb 3, 2020
Messages
36
I've been using and building PCs since 1985 and using high end Macs since 2010. Most software runs fine on both and that includes the Adobe CC suite. But beware, MAC GPU support is not widespread in some areas, notably with some 3D renderers such as Redshift. But that's a pretty specialist area. Generally the build quality and screens on both MacBooks and iMacs are fab. More expensive for sure. Screen and build quality apart, you generally get a better bang for your bucks with PCs.

As an aside, we are still using MacBooks from 2010. Not sure I could say that I was still using any PC derivative 10 years after I bought it.
 

Ryan Ashbrook

IPS Developer
Joined
Jan 26, 2004
Messages
3,538
As an aside, we are still using MacBooks from 2010. Not sure I could say that I was still using any PC derivative 10 years after I bought it.

My MacBook Pro is nearing ten years old as well, and I still use it. Not really for work purposes anymore, though - I use my iMac for that.

If I replace it anytime soon, it'll be because I just want something newer, rather than out of necessity.

When I used PC's, they generally had a lifespan of five to seven years but that was mostly because I constantly tinkered with them, which probably resulted in me breaking them down faster than they would normally.
 

mysiteguy

Migration Expert
Joined
Feb 20, 2007
Messages
3,124
There's no reason why a PC wouldn't last as long unless you buy the cheapest machine barely able to work with the current version of Windows. I have a couple of 15+ year-old machines here working just fine with Windows 10, including a laptop - and several 5 to 10 year-old-systems still actively used.

My primary system upgrades have not been because the current one couldn't do the job. Its always been to take advantage of faster CPUs, higher maximum RAM and faster I/O buses to do the work quicker. Microsoft has a pretty good track record of supporting 1-2+ older hardware generations when the OS has a major upgrade. A 10-year-old Mac is no different, it can continue to work but a newer Mac is going to do CPU/RAM intensive work quicker.
 
Last edited:

zappaDPJ

Administrator
Joined
Aug 26, 2010
Messages
7,435
There's no reason why a PC wouldn't last as long unless you buy the cheapest machine barely able to work with the current version of Windows. I have a couple of 15+ year-old machines here working just fine with Windows 10, including a laptop - and several 5 to 10 year-old-systems still actively used.

Reading that reminded me the first PC I bought cost more and did less than any other computer I've bought since. It came with 1 MB of RAM, a 1.2 MB floppy drive and a 40 MB hard drive. Add an EGA card, colour monitor and a maths co-processor (I think) which I did, the total price for a Compaq Deskpro 386 was approx. $8,000 or $18,000 in today's money. Although it was the fastest PC money could buy I replaced it very quickly :facepalm:

Since then I've built my own PCs from parts and I agree, 10 to 15 years with the occasional upgrade is easily achievable.
 

Chemical

Aspirant
Joined
Feb 3, 2020
Messages
36
A 10-year-old Mac is no different, it can continue to work but a newer Mac is going to do CPU/RAM intensive work quicker.

Quicker doesn't make it better unless your day depends on it. It just so happens that I work in an industry that needs as much horsepower as it can get, but that's not the case for most. Besides that, not many PCs or Macs are built like they used to be. A MacBook from 2010 is built to a much higher standard than its 2020 equivalent, offering a much nicer experience, even if a bit slower.
 

Chemical

Aspirant
Joined
Feb 3, 2020
Messages
36
Reading that reminded me the first PC I bought cost more and did less than any other computer I've bought since. It came with 1 MB of RAM, a 1.2 MB floppy drive and a 40 MB hard drive. Add an EGA card, colour monitor and a maths co-processor (I think) which I did, the total price for a Compaq Deskpro 386 was approx. $8,000 or $18,000 in today's money. Although it was the fastest PC money could buy I replaced it very quickly :facepalm:

Since then I've built my own PCs from parts and I agree, 10 to 15 years with the occasional upgrade is easily achievable.

I was a product manager at Autodesk in the 90s and for rendering, 386 Compaqs with Weitek copros were the order of the day. Luckily they were provided FOC by Compaq :)
 

Ryan Ashbrook

IPS Developer
Joined
Jan 26, 2004
Messages
3,538
There's no reason why a PC wouldn't last as long unless you buy the cheapest machine barely able to work with the current version of Windows. I have a couple of 15+ year-old machines here working just fine with Windows 10, including a laptop - and several 5 to 10 year-old-systems still actively used.

To be clear, any reason a computer I had that didn't last longer than five years was purely my fault lol.
 

mysiteguy

Migration Expert
Joined
Feb 20, 2007
Messages
3,124
To be clear, any reason a computer I had that didn't last longer than five years was purely my fault lol.
Worst for me was trying to glue a hinge on a laptop that was still under warranty because I didn't want to be without it for a week. It was the first time I used the particular kind of glue and I didn't know it expands (greatly) as it dries! $1800 laptop trashed by that bad decision.
 
Last edited:

overcast

Adherent
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Messages
486
My PC machines are kind of beginner level Lenovo right now. In past I had Dell machine and prior to that HP machine. But I guess the current low performance is due to low RAM, I have 4GB that goes slow. I can do better with linux with this RAM but windows not so much.
 

Buriwuh

Neophyte
Joined
Oct 9, 2019
Messages
9
Hi,
I'm planning to buy a pc to do some editing to create some YouTube videos. What will be the great companion for me?
If you are planning to do video editing, it is better to choose Mac. Its OS and software are perfect for video editing.
 

we_are_borg

Administrator
Joined
Jan 25, 2011
Messages
5,562
If you are planning to do video editing, it is better to choose Mac. Its OS and software are perfect for video editing.
Well Final Cute Pro is a very good software for video editing these days PC has good software to.
 

Steve M

Coder Formerly Known As..
Joined
Jan 6, 2010
Messages
850
I have both. Custom built PC by me and my MacBook Pro mid-2012 model. I've replaced the battery, plug, keyboard, track mouse, upgraded RAM, and my HDD with an SSD on my mac. Still runs strong and I use it for coding while my PC is for content creation and gaming. I can't buy a new Mac for at least 2 more years. That was the agreement I made with my wife that I won't trade it in for a newer model for at least 10 years. When I do, I'll probably trade it in and get me an iMac.
 

Chemical

Aspirant
Joined
Feb 3, 2020
Messages
36
If you are planning to do video editing, it is better to choose Mac. Its OS and software are perfect for video editing.
We are currently running iMac Pros which, when we bought them, had better i/o than standard iMacs. Three years on we are now in the market for upgrades and unless we opt for afterburner equipped Mac Pros ($$$), we will probably go the PC route simply because GPU support is still better on PCs and that matters if you are running something like Boris FX (effects and Mocha Pro) as part of the editing, masking, grading cycle.

We've also not managed to get MS FS running well on Bootcamp yet, either on our iMac Pros or i9 MacBooks with 64GB ram, so there's also another reason to want to go the PC route.

1984 - Meigs airfield Chicago.
1605962851175.png

2020
1605962314857.png
 
Top