But again, you're not really proposing how you'd improve it. I can agree that having options as to what gets displayed would not be a bad thing, but how you'd present it in an improved manner is another thing. I offered one possible solution above, but if you have a problem clicking tabs, then you probably also wouldn't enjoy clicking to expand a bunch of tree menus either. Which brings me back to square one. People are complaining about the readability of the current activity page, but I'm not seeing any better solutions being proposed to improve it. Perhaps just a clear separation of all activity by date would be a minor improvement, but other than that I'm not sure how you'd better present it.
Also, judging by your comment that the current system "pushes" them to it, you seem to think that most people, if given the choice, would end up preferring to have all their content mushed together on one page, and I'm not really sure that would be the case. I feel fairly confident that you would then have a lot of users asking how they could separate content to focus on what's most important to them. I suppose you could add filters to the page, which would be kind of cool, but I'm not sure that would be any "easier" than just clicking a tab....
. So far the only tracker I know of is Digital Point's which has always shown XF with quite the lead (probably missing a ton of things to consider but so far it's the only comparison I know of).
